Cancellation Watch Weekly Roundup: What We Do in the Shadows Drops, Creepshow Has Decent Debut, and More

Weekly Roundup: Ratings results and status updates on all the currently airing sci fi & fantasy shows as well as those still awaiting word on their fates. For the latest ratings updates throughout the week, be sure to follow the Cancelled Sci Fi Twitter Site

Ratings Results of Interest:  On Wednesday, FX’s What We Do in the Shadows took a notable drop, after several weeks of improving ratings, to a 0.15 rating based on same-day viewing for the 18-49 demographic with 378K total viewers. That show saw some similar swings to its ratings last season and could rebound next week, and it likely makes up some slack with digital viewing, so there is no cause for alarm at this point.

On Sunday, Starz’s Outlander wrapped up its fifth season with a 0.11 rating and 855K total viewers.  That show will be returning for a sixth season next year.  Over on Showtime, Penny Dreadful City of Angels remained low at a 0.04 rating with 352K total viewers.  Its chances for a second season remain in doubt.  Over on The CW, Batwoman and Supergirl held steady at a 0.2 and 0.1 rating respectively.

On Friday, MacGyver posted a 0.6 rating with 5.8 million total viewers for the final episode of its production-shutdown-impacted fourth season. That show was renewed last week by CBS for a fifth season last week. On Thursday, Freeform’s Siren improved slightly to a 0.11 rating with 406K total viewer, but it remains On the Bubble. Over on Syfy, Vagrant Queen slipped to a 0.03 rating with 208K total viewers as its prospects continue to sink.

On Freeform on Wednesday, Motherland Fort Salem ticked up to a 0.09 rating, but fans need to continue lobbying for that one on the social nets if they want it to return for a second season.  On Tuesday on The CW, The Flash and Legends of Tomorrow held steady at a 0.4 rating and 0.2 rating respectively.

On Monday, the premiere of the encore run for Creepshow pulled a 0.14 rating with 464K total viewers. Those are not spectacular numbers, but much better than what Dispatches from Elsewhere was pulling in the same hour and decent for an encore run of a streaming show. Over on The CW, Roswell New Mexico slipped to a 0.1 rating with 644K as that one does not have much of a lead-in at this point.

Most of the rest of the shows held mostly even with prior performance or did not air new episodes. You can see the full ratings results for the week at this link, and be sure to follow the Cancelled Sci Fi Twitter Site for the latest results and breaking news and to join the #CancelledSciFiArmy as we fight to save our sci fi shows.  For more info on what the ratings mean and how I use them to gauge the status of a show, check our our Cancelled Sci Fi FAQ Page.  Ratings Source: ShowBuzzDaily

>ALSO READ:Weekly Sci Fi TV Top 5: FOX Could Move NeXt to Fall, National Treasure TV Series in the Works at Disney+, and More

Renewal and Cancellation Announcements: This was supposed to be Upfront week when the broadcast networks unveil their schedules for the upcoming season, but that has been impacted by the Coronavirus shutdowns. Some announcements have been trickling in, though, and I expect more this week and throughout May. Among the announcements so far, the CBS spy fi series MacGyver has been renewed for a fifth season after its fourth year was cut short by the production shutdowns.  History Channel decided not to bring back its UFO-investigation drama Project Blue Book for a third season as that network appears to be shying away from scripted series.  Stay tuned to this site and the Cancelled Sci Fi Twitter Site for more breaking news and updates in the coming weeks.

Status Updates: Siren Could Use a Call to Action from Fans

Below are the status updates for all the currently airing shows or those still awaiting word on their fate, including those on the streaming services. You can click through to the show pages to see week-over-week ratings results (where available) and find out more information about the series.  You can see the status of all the currently airing and returning sci fi TV shows at our Cancellation Watch Page.

Currently Airing / Streaming Shows:

Amazing Stories (Apple TV+, Status – Renewal Possible): So far, Apple TV+ has renewed most of its original series, so consider this one to have a decent chance of coming back for a second season.

Batwoman (CW, Status – Renewed): While probably not the breakout hit The CW hoped for, this show is currently its second highest rated Fall entry. As expected, it has been renewed for a second season and I would expect it to stick around beyond that.  More on that at this link.

Charmed (CW, Status – Renewed): The numbers were down a bit in Fall for this show because of its move to Fridays, but it should do well in digital viewing like it did last season (The CW pays more attention to those stats than the other broadcast networks). It has been renewed for a third season.

The Flash (CW, Status – Renewed): This show remained as The CW’s top-rated show in Fall and will now take up the torch for the Arrow-verse shows with Arrow coming to an end.  It has been renewed for a seventh season, and it could stick around a year or two beyond that.  More on that at this link.

Future Man (Hulu, Status – Final Season): As is typical of the streaming services, this show is ending with its third season. But that at least gives it the chance to wrap up its storylines.

Harley Quinn (DCU, Status – Renewal Possible): This animated entry proved popular in its first season and had a quick turnaround for its second year. At this point, a third season looks like a good.

I Am Not Okay With This (Netflix, Status – Renewal Possible): As with any Netflix original series, this show has a decent chance of sticking around for a second season. But don’t expect an extended run because the streamer tends to cap off its shows around the third season.

Into the Dark (Hulu, Status – Renewal Possible): This horror-movie-a-month anthology continues to draw good buzz in its second season and Hulu could keep it around for another year or so.

Legends of Tomorrow (CW, Status – Renewed): This show was renewed for a sixth season ahead of its fifth year premiere, but there is a good chance that it will wrap after the 2020-21 season.  More on that at this link.

MacGyver (CBS, Status – Renewed): Production on the fourth season was been suspended due to the Coronavirus, but CBS certainly wanted to get this one to a syndication friendly count of episodes and has renewed it for a fifth season.

Motherland Fort Salem (Freeform, Status – On the Bubble): The numbers for this freshman series continue to drop and I have moved it to Bubble status.  Fans are currently making a Call to Action on the social networks to convince Freeform to bring it back for a second year and the show leads our season end poll.

Outlander (Starz, Status – Renewed): The viewership is down for this show in its fifth season, but it is likely making up some of the slack with delayed and digital viewing.  This is an established franchise for Starz that appeals directly to its female-skewing audience, and it has already been renewed through its a sixth season. Don’t be surprised if it continues beyond that as well.

Penny Dreadful City of Angels (Showtime, Status – On the Bubble): The premiere numbers for this show are not good, and even though the premium cable channels pay less attention to the same-day viewing, those stats do act as a leading indicator for viewer interest. This show will be starting out On the Bubble.

Primal (Adult Swim, Status – Renewal Possible): This show’s numbers are decent for a cable series these days, especially one airing at midnight. Five more episodes are planned for the first season and will air in 2020. If the numbers remain where they are at, Adult Swim could bring this one back for a second season.

Riverdale (CW, Status – Renewed): The numbers have slipped for this show in its fourth season–especially in Spring–but it likely makes up the gap in digital viewing which its network pays attention to (unlike the other broadcasters). It has been renewed for a fifth season and could stick around beyond that.

Roswell New Mexico (CW, Status – Renewed): This show has returned down some in the ratings from its first season, but that is the trend we have been seeing of late. It airs on The CW, aka the Happy Net, so it has already been renewed for a third season and could stick around beyond that.

Siren (Freeform, Status – On the Bubble): The numbers for this show have improved slightly the last two weeks, but I am still keeping it at Bubble status.  Fans may want to make a Call to Action on the social networks to help it get a fourth season renewal.

Solar Opposites (Hulu, Status – Renewal Possible): Hulu is claiming that this freshman animated series from the Rick and Morty team is its top original comedy and it was the second-most-watched show on the streaming service during its premiere week.  Expect a second season renewal announcement for this one to be arriving soon.

Star Wars The Clone Wars (Disney+, Status – Final Season): This will be the final season for Star Wars: The Clone Wars and will wrap up the major storylines from the series. Don’t be surprised if some specials / movies or a spin-off focusing on Ahsoka show up on Disney+ in the coming years, though.

Supergirl (CW, Status – Renewed): This show has been renewed for a sixth season, but don’t be surprised if that is announced as its last at some point.  More on that at this link.

Tales from the Loop (Amazon, Status – Renewal Possible): As with any original series on the streaming services, this one has a decent chance of coming back for a second season if the creative team has more stories planned. But the streaming shows tend to cap off around the third or fourth season mark.

Vagrant Queen (Syfy, Status – Cancellation Likely): The early numbers for this freshman series are not good, and Syfy has moved it out of Prime Time which almost assures it is headed for cancellation. It is currently in second place in our season end poll and should continue their Call to Action on the social networks to bring more attention to the show because its prospects are sinking fast.

Westworld (HBO, Status – Renewed): The same-day viewing for this show is down notably for its third season, but it continues to do well in delayed and digital viewing as well as the encore runs.  HBO has renewed the show for a fourth season and it could stick around beyond that.

What We Do in the Shadows? (FX, Status – Renewal Possible): This show has returned for its second season with numbers up from its first year, which is about the best a basic cable series can hope for these days. As long as it does not slip too much in the coming weeks, it should be on track for a third season renewal.

Season Ended But Still Awaiting Renewal / Cancellation Decision:

Altered Carbon (Netflix, Status – Renewal Possible): Word is that this one almost did not make it to a second season, and Netflix has been in the cancelling business of late. Perhaps Anthony Mackie’s presence will revive interest in the show, though, and allow it to stick around for at least one more year.

Black Mirror (Netflix, Status – Renewal Possible): There has been no word on this show since its fifth season debuted in June.  Netflix tends to end its originals around the three season mark, but this is one of the streamer’s flagship originals and they make an event out of the release of each season.  I expect at least a couple more seasons from this one.

Castle Rock (Hulu, Status: Renewal Possible): This season-long horror anthology series released is second season in Fall and could very well be on track for a third year renewal. But the streaming service has been quiet about its status since wrapping up in December. A Call to Action from fans on the social networks could help nudge Hulu execs in the direction of a renewal as they currently consider its fate.

The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance (Netflix, Status – Renewal Possible): This show has been well-recieved thus far (currently holding an 86% Fresh Rating and 94% Audience Score on Rotten Tomatoes) and has a decent chance of returning for a second season if the creative team wish to continue the story.

Devs (Hulu, Status – Renewal Possible): This show is being billed as a “limited series”, but if it has a large enough audience in its first season, it could get extended to a second year or more.

Dispatches from Elsewhere (AMC, Status – Cancellation Likely): The numbers for this show dropped off notably throughout the season despite a strong lead-in from Better Call Saul. At this point, it seems unlikely it will return for a second season unless it has international financing and/or syndications deals which would keep it viable.

Emergence (ABC, Status – On the Bubble): This is one of ABC’s lowest-rated dramas based on same-day ratings, and its delayed viewing gains faded as the season progressed.  I had moved it to Cancellation Likely status, but recent events with production shut-downs for other shows may work out favorably for Emergence.  More on that at this link.

Manifest (NBC, Status – Renewal Likely): The numbers for this show improved as it wrapped up its second season, and it continues to be one of the top performers across the broadcast networks in delayed viewing.  With the networks likely looking at a shortage of programming for Fall 2020 due to Coronavirus shutdowns, consider this show’s renewal chances to have vastly improved.

Project Blue Book (History, Status – Cancelled): This show returned down some from its first season numbers, but it was doing well enough in its second year for a basic cable series, especially in the total viewers metric.  History Channel appears to be shying away from scripted series, though, and this one was cancelled after two seasons.

The Purge (USA, Status – On the Bubble): This show’s numbers were down from its first year, and it faded notably with its season finale. The fact that it wrapped up in Fall and USA has still not made a third season announcement is concerning as well. It was originally billed as an “event series”, and that event may be coming to an end soon unless fans make a Call to Action to convince the network to bring this one back for another year.

SuperMansion (Crackle, Status – Renewal Possible): There has been no word on a fourth season of this show, but it has done well for Crackle so far and has also performed well in its encore run on Adult Swim. It released another special as recently as April 2019 and that might be its output for a while as the principals try to work in enough time in their schedules to produce more episodes.

The Terror (AMC, Status – On the Bubble): After proving to be a hit for AMC in its first season, this show returned with ratings down notably in its second year. But the series reboots itself each year, and network execs are currently listening to pitches for a third season. A Call to Action from fans on the social networks could help give this one an extra boost.

Two Sentence Horror Stories (CW, Status – Renewal Possible): There has been no word on this show since wrapping up its Summer run, but as a CW entry, it could always return.  Don’t be surprised if it quietly rejoins the schedule in Summer 2020.

Watchmen (HBO, Status – Renewal Possible): While the same-day viewing numbers for this show were soft in its first season, it did very well in delayed and digital viewing.  Series creator Damon Lindelof has said that “there are no current plans to make” to make a second season, but he doesn’t want to “close the door completely” on a continuation.  If there is a second season, it may be a few years down the road.

You can see the list of all of this season’s renewals and cancellations at this link.


>PREVIOUS POST: City of Angels Has Dreadful Debut, What We Do in the Shadows Improves, and more


More from CancelledSciFi.com:

Follow our Sci Fi TV Top 5 column for the top sci fi TV stories each week.

Check out our Sci Fi TV Schedule for debut and season finale dates and follow our Weekly Listings for a rundown of the shows airing in the current week.

Check back each Saturday for Sci Fi TV Retrospectives: A look back at cancelled, classic, forgotten, and more genre shows from the past.

Author: johnnyjay

2 thoughts on “Cancellation Watch Weekly Roundup: What We Do in the Shadows Drops, Creepshow Has Decent Debut, and More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.