Cancelled Too Soon: American Gothic (1995)

Our ongoing look back at sci fi / fantasy TV shows that were cancelled way too soon or pilots that never made it to series.

This quirky and unique horror series showed up on CBS’ schedule in the Fall of 1995 but unfortunately did not survive past a single season. It takes place in the small town of Trinity South Carolina where the sinister Sheriff Lucas Buck has a power over the people he polices and wants to bring the young, mysteriously wise Caleb Temple (recently orphaned due to his father’s suicide), under his control. The versatile Gary Cole (whose rolls have ranged from Brady dad in the Brady Bunch revival movies, starship captain in Babylon 5 spin-off series Crusade, and trolling middle-management boss in Office Space) delivered a standout performance as the show’s antagonist. While Lucas Black avoided the cute kid trope and provided an excellent co-lead as the young Caleb Temple. And Paige Turco stood her ground with both of these actors in one of her earlier television roles. The show delivered creepy, engaging tales held together by a loose story arc, and there was almost nothing on television at the time that matched its creepiness except maybe The X-Files which was just hitting its stride.

American Gothic came from the Hercules/Xena crew of Sam Raimi and Robert G. Tapert as well as creator Shaun Cassidy, but it struggled to find an audience during its initial run as it diverged considerably from the standard Prime Time fare (further frustrated by the network airing its episodes out of order). CBS cancelled it after one season, though it would go on to develop a strong cult following and there were plans to reboot the property on the big screen around 2004. Gary Cole would have returned as Sheriff Lucas Buck, and several other series regulars were set to reprise their roles with Sam Raimi returning as producer. A new actor would have played Caleb, though, as Lucas Black had grown too old to play the character. However, the movie plans stalled over various concerns and were eventually shelved altogether in 2005. The full series is available on DVD, and apparently the creative team had enough notice of the cancellation that they were able to give some resolution to the main storylines by the final episodes. It is definitely worth seeking out for those who have never seen the show and also deserving of a revisit for those who have not seen it in years.

Aired: CBS, 1995-96, 1 Season Totaling 22 Episodes

Created By: Shaun Cassidy

Starring: Gary Cole, Lucas Black, Paige Turco, Jake Weber

More from CancelledSciFi.com:

Keep up with the ratings developments and the status of all the currently airing sci fi and fantasy shows with our Weekly Roundup posts. And join the #CancelledSciFiArmy on Twitter to bolster our ranks and help us fight for the struggling and cancelled sci fi and fantasy shows.

Follow our Sci Fi TV News Briefs column for a rundown of the latest news and updates on genre television.

Check out our Sci Fi TV Schedule for debut and season finale dates and follow our Weekly Listings for a rundown of the shows airing in the current week.

Author: admin

4 thoughts on “Cancelled Too Soon: American Gothic (1995)

  1. I bought the series on DVD. It was a great show, and I was very angry when they cancelled it! The catch phase, “There’s someone at the door” sent chills down my spine! I became a big fan of Gary Cole then, and I’m still a big fan. I was amazed that it came from Shaun Cassidy, but found that he was a terrifically talented writer and producer! I loved his show Invasion, too, as well as others. The way Gary’s character went walking through the jail whistling the theme from the Andy Griffith show, was brilliant! This was a truly imaginative show. No zombies, werewolves or vampires in sight, just chillingly imaginative characters. It’s now 2021, and after all these years, I still regret its cancellation! Imaginative series like this no longer exist!

  2. I first saw this show, when I must have been around 13 or 14, at the same time as my parents watched it back in 1995. I think the show had a lot of promise/started off well (even though by today’s standards some of the visual effects could be considered dated).
    I think it was a major mistake for this to end up cancelled as early in as it was.

    I was recently able to get this on Apple TV for £13 anyhow! So far have watched the first 4 or 5 episodes, and am enjoying the rewatch.

  3. It was a shame that it stopped after one season. I could tell that it was building up to more and more and then it suddenly stopped. They wrapped it all up, they had to have known it was ending on the last episode.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.